DISCLAIMER: This is not a review of Wall-e, instead it is something I have been thinking about since watching it. I don't reveal any Story plot, but if you are like me and avoid ALL material related to a new movie then you might not want to read on.On Friday there I went to see 'Wall-e' in the cinema, its Pixar, it's compulsory. However, upon leaving I was a tad unsettled. I felt that as a person who has just left a Computer Arts course that I should have been astounded yet again by the visual brilliance that Pixar bring with each new movie... I was not.
Don't get me wrong, I did like the perfect-as-always animation, the various robotic characters and all the subtle ideas that I know I will only pick up on the fourth viewing; it is a good movie. My problem is with the visual style.
Previous Pixar movies have been 3D cartoons. 'The Incredibles' was stylised to fit that superhero theme, with their over and under proportioned body parts (look at the size of their feet!).
It appeared that with Wall-e, Pixar had wanted to make it less like a cartoon and actually quite real, and in this they succeeded gracefully, but its something I was not expecting at all.
I mean, if you took Nemo and placed him in a tank with other fish in real life you'd be like "Shit, whats wrong with that fish! It's a mutant or something!". If you placed Remy in with other rats in a cage you would think some kid had dropped thier fluffy toy rat in amongst them. What I'm saying is a 3D model from previous Pixar movies would look out of place in real life, but if you seen Wall-e or EVE down the street it would look like someone had actually built them right there with real material from real life. Or even if you walked into Wall-e's little home you would not think "Fuck, I'm in a cartoon".
When I watch a Pixar movie I want to think "Fuck, I'm in a cartoon".
Even had Fred Willard in it, like live action. It was a cool touch, but wasn't 'Pixar'.
On saying all that... it was beautiful. Maybe its just something that I need to get used to. If Nintendo suddenly came out with a realistic looking game I'm sure that it would be as good as any Mario, Zelda or Metroid outting.
PS. The short that precedes the movie, 'Presto', is one of my favourite cinema moments and that alone was worth the £6 cinema ticket.